Login or Register

  Welcome: Guest

Home >> Article >> World News >> Social >> Post New Article Bookmark and Share

Mashelkar Report controversy.

May 19, 2010  by: Rahul  Points: 25   Category: Social  Earning $0.30   Views: 864

Mashelkar Report controversy. The Patents (Amendment) Bill, 2005, introduced in the Parliament in March


"The Patents (Amendment) Bill, 2005, introduced in the Parliament in March, 2005 with the objective of making the Patents Act compatible with India's international obligations, particularly under the Agreement on Trade Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS Agreement) had the benefit of detailed discussion in both the Houses. During the debate, the issues regarding patentability of micro-organisms and the definition of 'pharmaceutical substance' to mean "a new chemical entity (NCE)" or "new medical entity (NME)" were raised. The Commerce and Industry Minister then assured the Parliament that he would refer these issues to an Expert Committee for detailed examination and report the matter to the Parliament."

Accordingly, a Technical Expert Group on Patent Law Issues was set up by the Government of India, Ministry of Commerce & Industry, Department of Industrial Policy & Promotion in April, 2005.

The terms of reference for the expert group were:

1. Whether it would be TRIPS compatible to limit the grant of patent for pharmaceutical substance to new chemical entity or to new medical entity involving one or more inventive steps; and
2. Whether it would be TRIPS compatible to exclude micro-organisms from patenting.

Why it ran into trouble was that it was accused of plagiarism. The report had lifted three paragraphs in its conclusion from a 2005 paper authored by a research scholar Mr. Shamnad Basheer. His research work was commissioned by the UK based Intellectual Property Institute.

But in the subsequent that was raised about it is very easy to forget the recommendations of the committee on the terms of reference. What are they?

1. On the first point of reference, it has answered that it would not be TRIPS compliant to limit granting of patents to New Chemical Entities only. Patents are to be granted for incremental innovations.
1. It is worthwhile to note that at present, under Indian laws there is NO patent protection for incremental innovations. So this recommendation of the committee, is seen by the red brigade as a pro-MNC stance of the committee.
2. On excluding micro-organisms from patenting, it observed that such exclusion would be violative of TRIPS Agreement.

**As of today, the position is that the government says that it cannot act on the report unless the 'technical inaccuracies' are corrected. But Mr. Mashelkar says that, as he has resigned from the Committee, there is nothing more that he needs to do.


No response found. Be the first to respond to this post

Post Comment

Please Log In  to post comment

Related Resources

Tips For Making A Good Report
A report is a written statement or document stating what has happened or describing the state of affairs.It is written in a clear, informative way, drawing conclusions, making recommendations and suggesting course of action.

Report of Day 2 Test 1 - India Vs. Australia
The second day saw a strong Indian reply to the first innings Australian score of 333 all out. Earlier, the Indian bowlers cleaned up the Aussie tail reasonably quickly.

Report of Day 1 Test 1 - India Vs. Australia
Honors were shared by both India and Australia on the first day of the first Test being played at Melbourne. India managed to pick up 6 Australian wickets, while the hosts managed to score 277 runs at the end of day one.

Detail information on education from education report-2011
In this article, I have given information on education report-2011 by government of India.

An Interview with Yuvaraj a report
Yuvaraj Singh is one of the successfull batsman of indian cricket. When India won the world cup if became the man of the series. Nowadays he is out of the team due to cancer(fine now). This is article says about the interview with Yuvaraj Singh by a reporter.

Latest Resources From The Same Category

Technical Gadgets were invented to Connect, but they still not able to Connect
Yes, there are plethora of ways, to connect these days, from house of technology; which earlier, were not available in non-technological era. People residing in faraway lands, were not able to connect because of no technology in non-technological era.

Peace days of Letters Days
Yes, once there were days, when there comes post letters; but now only comes postpaid bills. Now, there is technology and when there was no technology; people send letters to each other, at both times. Even, when technology era started; but was not advanced so much, like it is now; people still send letters to each other at that time.

Results of Cheap lies of Certain People Really Needy People Suffer
Yes, people have become such like these days that they does not want to pay price of anything, want to have everything for free. It is not like that they does not have money, they have but still do not want to pay, and even rich people want things for free.

Better Late than Never
It is hot summer now and we are undergoing a severe water shortage. When the urbanization got acceleration in the recent decades, we lost a lot of water bodies and farm lands which helped to keep the ground water level intact. Due to urbanization, we lost large areas of forest and the ecology got disrupted at many places. This resulted in the present day water crisis. Now Indian Meteorological department predicts a normal monsoon this year. This is the right time to take the necessary steps to p

Greetings on the Mothers Day
Today is Mothers Day. I think of all moms and greet them. I greet my dear mom in heaven. I think of the days of my mom''''''''s life spent on this earth in selfless love. It has been encouraging and enlightening to me every second of my life. I think of the heavenly Mom who protects me every second.


Top Performers     Top Contributors     Share and Earn     Terms of Service    Privacy Policy     Contact Us